| Learning and Change in the Adult Years Mark Tennant and Philip Pogson Jossey-Bass Publishers, 1995 ISBN 0-7879-0082-5 200 pages
Maureen Connolly, Elmhurst College,IL
The authors develop three themes: development of thought and knowledge; development of self; and the relationship between adult development and adult education practice. Each of the chapters is complete with references to studies, articles, and other books of numerous educators ranging from Stephen Brookfield to Cyril Houle to David Kolb. What this reviewer found most interesting was the concept of practical intelligence and expertise. Research was initiated because of dissatisfaction with the limitations of intelligence tests that lacked the ability to adequately measure practical intelligence and give value to it. In recent times, there has been a slow but steady research effort to consider the differences between practical and academic problem solving. The authors argue that Western
culture has always been biased in favor of abstract over practical, the
thinker over the doer. They argue for the validity and status of
practical intelligence by laying a framework that begins with citing a
definition of intelligence, which includes the practical aspect, and reporting
on the Scribner model of practical thinking. Experience, in turn,
operates with intelligence to produce expertise. Expertise is explained
with reference to studies on medical expertise. However, expertise
needs to be further distinguished. It can be viewed as an
outcome or as a process. Adult educators need to consider how experience
will make a person an expert. Overall, Tennant and Pogson offer
food for thought on this topic. |